OTA YOSHIMOTO; AKITA MOTOMU
近畿大学生物理工学部紀要 近畿大学 15 (15) 1 - 13 1342-7202 2005/03
[Refereed] Ancient Greek physician Hippocrates (460?-377? BC), the Father of Medicine, established an oath and asked the people who intend to be a physician to take the oath. In this Hippocratic oath starting as "I swear by Apollo Physician and Asclepius and Hygieia and Panaceia and all the gods and goddesses, making them my witnesses, that I will fulfil according to my ability and judgment this oath and this covenant : ", there is a sentence saying "...I will apply dietetic measures for the benefit of the sick according to my ability and judgment ; I will keep them from harm and injustice. ..." That is to say, life is respectable and the balance of benefit resulting from any actions to life must be over harm. The oath shows that, from those olden times, the importance of ethical consideration in relation to any actions of medicine affecting human life has been recognized by medical professionals. Today, scientists have made clear the subtle architecture of life in detail at the level of molecules, and have made it possible to manipulate genes of organism. They, as ancient Greek physician did, should consider seriously from ethical point of view about the balance between benefit and harm resulting from any actions applied to lives. This is particularly important for genetically modified (GM) crops, because crops are of fundamental importance for human life and their quality may influence directly human health. An ultimate benefit -good- resulting from GM crops is to ensure food for explosively increasing world population, and the confronting harm -bad- to this is uneasiness about safety as daily food and disturbance to natural environment. Even though scientists produced GM crops aiming at only the good, the final, decision to accept them will be made by the consumer. Thus, it is quite important to offer appropriate and understandable information about GM crop to the general public for making decision. In this respect, scientists who carry out the research at university have a responsibility to consider thoroughly on safety and ethical issue of GM crops and to educate students with appropriate manner. In this review, we discuss whether genetic modification of crops can be admitted ethically by trying to answer to public concern about the safety of transgenic crops as food and on environment.